Loading...

Feb 21, 2017

Confronting bad manners in Japan

I'm just wondering if anyone here has ever tried to confront Japanese people when they might be acting inconsiderately or with bad manners (on trains, in queues, and situations like that). If you have, what kind of reaction did you get? Maybe I'm getting grumpier as I get older but so far I've yet to do it but sometimes I feel I should.

DaveJpn

DaveJpn

Love travel, football, and a good read. Been in Japan for a little while now. Still loving it, still discovering new things, and still annoyed by how much packaging they wrap around snacks in this country.

10 Answers



Best Answer

  • Daiuchi

    on Feb 22

    When someone has bad manners or makes me feel uncomfortable I usually just give them a weird/upset face depending on the situation. Using the gaijin card they tend to stop right away without having to say anything and surprisingly they also don't like to be confrontational for the most part. The thing that really bothers me though is the rush for train seats. I've seen people knock over people in order to get a seat and not even apologize! When this happened to me once... I just stood in front of the person the whole way to make things awkward for them. I'm not really one to say things out loud but I don't think you should hesitate to confront someone if it's something that really bothers you. Especially on the train... manners on the train always seem to just disappear :(

    1
  • BigfamJapan

    on Feb 21

    I haven't, but this is timely as just today I felt like confronting someone. We were at a playground and there was a woman there with her child and she kept running down the slide in her shoes. It really bugged me! Maybe this is normal? I wanted to say "kids have to go down there on their bums, please don't run down it in your big clunky boots with muck on them." I was really really surprised at her to be honest and if truth be told a little disappointed in myself that I didn't say something. I decided to move on instead.Thankfully I rarely come across bad manners (rural area), if I was facing it a lot I may very well explode.

    1
  • BigfamJapan

    on Feb 21

    ...I do say something to unruly children though. A lot! But I think that is common here.

    1
  • ConeHead

    on Feb 22

    I usually say someone but in a pleasant way if it is not that bad. But last week I saw a customer reprimanding a clerk in the supermarket and I think, just based on her attitude, that she the customer was over doing it. With my limited Japanese, I didnt want to say anything and it wasnt what I think it was. I really wanted to stand up to that woman though,but I didnt. So I kept staring at her in a bad way, hoping she was say something to me, so I could take her on! lol

    1
  • Aluma

    on Feb 22

    I usually just say, "sumimasen" and make myself look really uncomfortable and that usually resolves the problem. A little passive aggressive, I know, but I'm super non-confrontational and usually use the "gaijin factor" to my benefit.

    2
  • edthethe

    on Feb 22

    ive called out highschooler for being rude. one was directed towards me as a heavier foreign woman. i spoke to him in japanese and let him know he was being rude. another incident i told off a boy for harassing another student the same way i would scold my own kids, but mixed english to really terrify the boy. i never saw him harass another student onb the train platform again. im not sure what i would have done if it had been an adult.

    2
  • DaveJpn

    on Feb 24

    @Daiuchi I'm right with you on the rushing for train seats thing!! In fact, better to not get me started on it - one of THE most annoying things for me. I try to give these people dirty looks, but given what they do, I don't think they care about anyone else anyway.

    0
  • DaveJpn

    on Feb 24

    @ConeHead I once saw something similar in a supermarket. An older Japanese guy was having a right go at one of the ladies working at the cash register. It was going on for ages before management stepped in. Actually, another 'gaijin' who was there at the time tried to step in, but he looked like he was enjoying too much rather than doing anything productive.

    0
  • JapanRamen

    on Feb 24

    I'm the say-nothing + stand in the way + evil stare type haha. The Japanese way is to go 'sumimasen' but it definitely isn't as effective (or threatening) than evil stares lol

    1
  • genkidesu

    on Nov 25

    I have -- and got ignored, by the person in question and everyone else on the train. It was when my daughter and I were on the shinkansen when she was about 3, and as we were trying to get to our seats, an old lady (70ish?) literally pushed past my daughter to get to her seat. Called her out on it verbally, she didn't make eye contact and neither did anyone else on the train. I don't think it's really the done thing here, and maybe she assumed that because she was older she had the right to shove a kid. Who knows.

    0

Awaiting More Answers

0 Answers

Summer reading

I know there have been questions in the past about what we're watching, but I'm wondering what you're reading at the moment! I'm looking to get a few new books for summer and I'd love to hear if you have any recent recommendations. If you have any good spots here to get EN language books in person, too, I'd appreciate if you would share those as well!

genkidesu

8 hours ago

18 Answers

Database error

Anyone else getting a database error after you log in? So far, it looks like I can still write posts, but I had trouble logging in and after log in my home page looks different to normal with a "database error" message.

BigfamJapan

on May 23

10 Answers

Condiments in your fridge?

Just for fun! I was thinking the other day how different the contents of my fridge are to the fridge I grew up with! Just one example, I always have soy sauce in my fridge and usually at least one other unopened bottle in the cupboard. There was never soy sauce in my fridge growing up. And the friends I grew up with don't have soy sauce in their fridges even now. But my Uni friends all have soy sauce in their fridges, because they all lived in Japan for at least a year. I was just wondering what things do you have in your fridge here that you probably wouldn't have in your fridge in your home country had you never lived here.

BigfamJapan

on May 9

9 Answers

Moving house process

I've been in my apartment for nearly 7 years. I've got my eye on an apartment one station closer to work. But I forgot what it was like to move in here! It was all a bit traumatic... Have you got some packing tips, suggestions for how to move your household goods, and what to save for last?

TonetoEdo

on May 3